GUI Paradigms (1): Redux (Flutter/React) translated to MATLAB

For GUI development, we often start with controls (or widgets) that user interact with and it’ll emit/run the callback function we registered for the event when the event happens.

Most of the time we just want to read the state/properties of certain controls, process them, and update other controls to show the result. Model-View-Controller (MVC) puts strict boundaries between interaction, data processing and display.

The most common schematic for MVC is a circle showing the cycle of Controller->Model->View, but in practice, it’s the controller that’s the brains. The view can simultaneously accept user interactions, such as a editable text box or a list. The model usually don’t directly update the view directly on its own like the idealized diagram.

MVC with User Action
From https://www.educative.io/blog/mvc-tutorial

With MVC, basically we are concentrating the control’s callbacks to the controller object instead of just letting each control’s callback interact with the data store (model) and view in an unstructured way.


When learning Flutter, I was exposed to the Redux pattern (which came from React). Because the tutorials was designed around the language features of Dart, the documentation kind of obscured the essence of the idea (why do we want to do this) as it dwelt on the framework (structure can be refactored into a package). The docs talked a lot about boundaries but wasn’t clearly why they have to be meticulously observed, which I’ll get to later.

The core inspiration in Redux/BLoC is taking advantage of the concept of ‘listening to a data object for changes’ (instead of UI controls/widget events)!

Instead of having the UI control’s callback directly change other UI control’s state (e.g. for display), we design a state vector/dictionary/struct/class that holds contents (state variables) that we care. It doesn’t have to map 1-1 to input events or 1-1 to output display controls.

When an user interaction (input) event emitted a callback, the control’s callback do whatever it needs to produce the value(s) for the relevant state variable(s) and change the state vector. The changed state vector will trigger the listener that scans for what needs to be updated to reflect the new state and change the states of the appropriate view UI controls.

This way the input UI controls’ callbacks do not have to micromanage what output UI controls to update, so it can focus on the business logic that generates the content pool that will be picked up by the view UI controls to display the results. In Redux, you are free to design your state variables to match more closely to the input data from UI controls or output/view controls’ state. I personally prefer a state vector design that is closer to the output view than input controls.


The intuition above is not the complete/exact Redux, especially with Dart/Flutter/React. We also have to to keep the state in ONE place and make the order of state changes (thus behavior) predictable!

  • Actions and reducers are separate. Every input control fires a event (action signal) and we’ll wait until the reducers (registered to the actions) to pick it up during dispatch() instead of jumping on it. This way there’s only ONE place that can change states. Leave all the side effects in the control callback where you generate the action. No side effects (like changing other controls) allowed in reducers!
  • Reducers do not update the state in place (it’s read only). Always generate a new state vector to replace the old one (for performance, we’ll replace the state vector if we verified the contents actually changed). This will make timing predictable (you are stepping through state changes one by one)

In Javascript, there isn’t really a listener actively listening state variable changes. Dispatch (which will be called every time the user interacts using control) just runs through all the listeners registered at the very end after it has dispatched all the reducers. In MATLAB, you can optionally set the state vector to be Observable and attach the change listener callback instead of explicitly calling it within dispatch.

https://gist.github.com/gaearon/ffd88b0e4f00b22c3159

Here is an example of a MATLAB class that captures the spirit of Redux. I added a 2 second delay to emulate long operations and used enableDisableFig() to avoid dealing with queuing user interactions while it’s going through a long operation.

classdef ReduxStoreDemo < handle

    % Should be made private later
    properties (SetAccess = private, SetObservable)
        state % {count}
    end
        
    methods (Static)
        % Made static so reducer cannot call dispatch and indirectly do
        % side effect or create loops
        function state = reducer(state, action)        
            % Can use str2fun(action) here or use a function map
            switch action
                case 'increment'
                    fprintf('Wait 2 secs before incrementing\n');
                    pause(2)
                    state.count = state.count + 1;
                    fprintf('Incremented\n');
            end                
        end        
    end
    
    % We keep all the side-effect generating operations (such as
    % temporarily changing states in the GUI) in dispatch() so
    % there's only ONE PLACE where state can change
    methods
        function dispatch(obj, action, src, evt)
            % Disable all figures during an interaction
            figures = findobj(groot, 'type', 'figure');
            old_fig_states = arrayfun(@(f) enableDisableFig(f, 'off'), figures);      
            src.String = 'Wait ...';
            
                new_state = ReduxStoreDemo.reducer(obj.state, action);
                
                % Don't waste cycles updating nops 
                if( ~isequal(new_state, obj.state) )
                    % MATLAB already have listeners attached.
                    % So no need to scan listeners like React Redux            
                    obj.state = new_state;
                end                
                
            % Re-enable figure obj.controls after it's done
            arrayfun(@(f, os) enableDisableFig(f, os), figures, old_fig_states);                        
            src.String = 'Increment';
        end
    end
    
    methods
        function obj = ReduxStoreDemo()
            figure();            
            obj.state.count = 0;                        
            
            h_1x  = uicontrol('style', 'text', 'String', '1x Box', ...
                              'Units', 'Normalized', ...
                              'Position', [0.1 0.3, 0.2, 0.1], ...
                              'HorizontalAlignment', 'left');                          
            addlistener(obj, 'state', ...
                        'PostSet', @(varargin) obj.update_count_1x( h_1x , varargin{:})); 
                        
            uicontrol('style', 'pushbutton', 'String', 'Increment', ...
                      'Units', 'Normalized', ...
                      'Position', [0.1 0.1, 0.15, 0.1], ...
                      'Callback', @(varargin) obj.dispatch('increment', varargin{:}));                             
            
            % Force trigger the listeners to reflect the initial state
            obj.state = obj.state;
        end
    end
    
    %% These are 'renders' registered when the uiobj.controls are created
    % Should stick to reading off the state. Do not call dispatch here
    % (just leave it for the next action to pick up the consequentials)
    methods
        % The (src, event) is useless for listeners because it's not the 
        % uicontrol handle but the state property's metainfo (access modifiers, etc)
        function update_count_1x(obj, hObj, varargin)            
            hObj.String = num2str(obj.state.count);
        end        
    end
    
end

 4 total views

Data Relationships of Spreadsheets: Relational Database vs. Heterogenous Data Tables

This blog post is development in process. Will fill in the details missing details (especially pandas) later. Some of the MATLAB syntax are inaccurate in the sense that it’s just a description that is context dependent (such as column names can be cellstr, char string or linear/logical indices).

From data relationship point of view, relation database (RDMBS), heterogenous data tables (MATLAB’s dataset/table or Python Panda’s Dataframe) are the same thing. But a proper database have to worry about concurrency issues and provide more consistency tools (ACID model).

Heterogenous data tables are almost always column-oriented database (mainly for analyzing data) where MySQL and Postgres are row-store database. You can think of column-store database as Struct of Arrays (SoA) and row-store database as Array of Struct (AoS). Remember locality = performance: in general, you want to put the stuff you frequently want to access together as close to each other as possible.

Mechanics:

ConceptsSQLMATLAB tablePandas Dataframe
tablesFROM(work with T)(work with df)
columns
variables
fields
SELECT T.(field)
T(:, cols/varnames)
rows
records
WHERE

HAVING
T( cond(T), : )

T_grp( cond(T_grp), : )
conditionsNOT
IS
IN
BETWEEN
~
==, isequal*()
ismember()
a<=b & b<=c
Inject table to
another table
INSERT INTO t2
SELECT vars FROM t1
WHERE rows
T2(end+(1:#rows), vars) = T1(rows, vars)
(Doable, throws warning)

Insert record/rowINSERT INTO t (c1, c2, ..)
VALUES (v1, v2, ..)
T=[T; {v1, v2, ...}]
(Cannot default for unspecified column*)
update records/elementsUPDATE table
SET column = content
WHERE row_cond
T.(col)(row_cond) = content
New table
from selection
SELECT vars
INTO t2
FROM t1
WHERE rows
T2 = T1(rows, vars)
clear tableTRUNCATE TABLE tT( :, : )=[]
delete rowsDELETE FROM t WHERE cond
(if WHERE is not specified, it kills all rows one by one with consistency checks. Avoid it and use TRUNCATE TABLE instead)
T( cond, : ) = []
* I developed sophisticated tools to allow partial row insertion, but it’s not something TMW supports right out of the box. This involves overloading the default value generator for each data type then extract the skeleton T( [], : ) to identify the data types.

Core database concepts:

ConceptsSQLMATLAB (table/dataset)Pandas (Dataframe)
linear indexCREATE INDEX idx ON T (col)T.idx = (1:size(T,1))'
group indexCREATE UNIQUE INDEX idx ON T (cols)[~, T.idx] = sortrows(T, cols)
(old implementation is grp2idx())
set operationsUNION
INTERSET
union()
intersect()
setdiff(), setxor()
sortORDER BYsortrows()
uniqueSELECT DISTINCTunique()
reduction
aggregration
F()@reductionFunctions
groupingGROUP BYSpecifying ‘GroupingVariables’ in varfun(), rowfun(), etc.
partitioning(set partition option in Table Definition)T1=T(:, {'key', varnames_1})
T2=T(:, {'key', varnames_2})
joins[type] JOIN*join(T1, T2, ...)df.join(df2, …)
cartesian productCROSS JOIN
(misnomer, no keys)
T_cross = [repelem(T1, size(T2,1), 1), repmat(T2, [size(T1,1), 1])]
Function programming concepts map (linear index), filter (logical index), reduce (summary & group) are heavily used with databases

Formal databases has a Table Definition (Column Properties) that must be specified ahead of time and can be updated in-place later on (think of it as static typing). Heterogenous Data Tables can figure most of that out on the fly depending on context (think of it as dynamic typing). This impacts:

  • data type (creation and conversion)
  • unspecified entries (NULL).
    Often NaN in MATLAB native types but I extended it by overloading relevant data types with a isnull() function and consistently use the same interface
  • default values
  • keys (Indices)

SQL features not offered by heterogenous data tables yet:

  • column name aliases (AS)
  • wildcard over names (*)
  • pattern matching (LIKE)

SQL features that are unnatural with heterogeneous data tables’ syntax:

  • implicitly filter a table with conditions in another table sharing the same key.
    It’s an implied join(T, T_cond)+filter operation in MATLAB. Often used with ANY, ALL, EXISTS

Fundamentally heterogenous data types expects working with snapshots that doesn’t update often. Therefore they do not offer active checking (callbacks) as in SQL:

  • Invariant constraints (CHECK, UNIQUE, NOT NULL, Foreign key).
  • Auto Increment
  • Virtual (dependent) tables (CREATE VIEW)

Know these database/spreadsheet concepts:

  • Tall vs wide tables

Language logistics (not related to database)

ConceptsSQLMATLAB (table/dataset)Pandas (Dataframe)
Partial displayMySQL: LIMIT
Oracle: FETCH FIRST
T( 1:10, : )df.head()
Comments-- or /* */% or %{ %}# or """"""
functionCREATE PROCEDURE fcnfunction [varargout{:}]=fcn(varargin{:})def fcn:
caseCASE WHEN THEN ELSE ENDswitch case end(no case structure, use dictionary)
Null if no resultsIFNULL ( statement )function X=null_if_empty(T, cond)
X=T( cond, : );
if( isempty(X) ) X=NaN;
Replace nullsISNULL(col, target_val)T.col(isnan(T.col)) = target_val
T = standardizeMissing( T, ... )

 35 total views,  1 views today